Vacation Rental vs. Traditional Leasing: Essential Differences and a Third Way

Fachada de Prédio em Guimarães com Alojamentos Locais geridos pela Host Wise

If you've purchased or inherited a property and want to turn it into a source of income, you're almost always faced with the same choice: long-term rental (a classic housing contract) or converting the house into a vacation rental (short-term rental for tourists, students, or professionals on a rotating basis). Each model brings different promises, risks, and obligations—and, until recently, forced the owner to choose between security and profit potential.

Host Wise has created a third model—Guaranteed Profitability—that resolves this dilemma, combining the predictability of traditional leasing with short-term operational benefits. Before we show you how it works, we'll walk through the two "classic" formats, including a point-by-point comparison, in a calm and jargon-free manner. By the end, you'll have a solid roadmap for deciding which one best suits your investor profile—or why it might make sense to delegate everything and secure the income, saving time and hassle.

 

 

Prédio com Alojamento Local gerido pela Host Wise

Traditional Lease: Stability in Exchange for Moderate Income

Long-term leases are based on housing legislation (Novo Regime do Arrendamento Urbano - NRAU) and contracts that generally last between three and five years.

  • Predictable cash flow: The agreed-upon rent is deposited into your account on a set date. If you wish to increase the amount, you must comply with legal limits and provide advance notice.
  • Simplified management: Once the contract is signed, your tasks are limited to issuing electronic receipts, monitoring payments, and addressing structural repairs.
  • Light legal obligations: written contract, notification to the tax authorities, energy certificate, and, in urban properties, an updated use permit.
  • Transparent taxation: IRS category F taxation; in practice, tax is paid on 70% to 90% of the income, depending on the regime chosen and the length of the contract.
For whom?
Investors averse to market fluctuations, residents abroad, or those simply without the time to contact guests daily.

 

 

Quarto de Alojamento Local em Gaia gerido pela Host Wise

Local Accommodation: Higher Revenue, Faster Pace

Local accommodation (AL) is a crossroads between hospitality and rentals. Owners need a "registration number" from the municipality, affix an identification sign, and comply with safety and security regulations.

  • Higher profit potential: Daily rates adjust according to the season, city events, and specific demand. During peak periods, the monthly rental price can be tripled.
  • Exposure to seasonality: School holidays, international fairs, or new flights fill up your schedule; parking your car during the low season can mean empty nights.
  • Management that's similar to a hotel: Check-ins, cleaning, laundry, responding to reviews, and maintaining inventory require time or a professional team.
  • Dynamic regulation: There are zones with maximum registration limits; municipalities can also revise tourism taxes or licensing requirements.
For whom?
Owners in tourist areas seek to maximize margins, accepting fluctuations in revenue and an operational learning curve.

 

Side-by-Side Comparison

 

Criteria Traditional Leasing  Vacation Rental
Typical Income Fixed, within the residential market value
Variable; high seasonal peaks
Income Volatility Low Medium to High
Owner Expenses Structural maintenance, property tax, condominium fees Cleaning, utilities, OTA fees, ongoing maintenance
Required Permits Contract + energy certificate AL registration, license plate, information book
Impact on future appreciation Preserved property, broader demand

Active AL license may increase in value in tourist markets

 

 

The classic impasse: "Do I choose profit or peace of mind?"

Many landlords experience this cycle:


1. They start with traditional rentals, enjoy the stability, but feel like they're "losing money" when they see neighboring apartments charging tourist rates.

2. Moving to a Vacation Rental is exciting—until the first phone calls at 2 a.m. or the electricity bill skyrockets in August.

3. They reevaluate their priorities (quality of life, free time, family) and want a way to combine financial advantage and predictability.

It was precisely to break this cycle that Host Wise designed Guaranteed Profitability.

 

 

The third way: Host Wise Guaranteed Profitability

Imagine transferring the lease to a "professional tenant" who:

  • pays you each month an amount higher than the average residential income in the area;
  • covers the costs of water, electricity, internet, condominium fees, insurance, and preventive maintenance;
  • updates the inventory (bedding, small appliances, utensils) whenever necessary and leaves it for you;
  • keeps the apartment available in excellent condition at the end of the agreement, making it available for rent, sale, or occupancy.

This is how Guaranteed Profitability works. In practice, the risks associated with seasonality, complaints, marketing, and logistics are transferred to Host Wise's operations, with hundreds of properties already under management and local teams across the country. The owner receives a fixed bank transfer, similar to a traditional rental, but without direct contact with tenants or guests, and with income typically 10-15% above the average long-term rental income for the area.

 

 

Conclusion

Between the peaceful stability of traditional rentals and the profit potential (but effort) of vacation rentals, there is now a hybrid solution: Host Wise Guaranteed Profitability. It delivers above-average residential income, maintains the property impeccably, and returns it with fresh inventory.


You don't have to waste nights deciding "A or B." Request a free simulation and see, in concrete terms, how your apartment can yield more, without sacrificing your time or peace of mind.

 

Reading next

Condomínio na Rua Formosa onde a Host Wise tem alojamento local